Homemade Salsa (Keto, Vegan, Paleo)

Homemade salsa is super simple to make and requires only a few ingredients you likely already have in your pantry.

Jump To

• This homemade salsa is:
• Why make your own salsa?
• What do you need to make homemade salsa?
• Tips and Substitutions
• Petite diced tomatoes
• Baby tomatoes
• Onion
• Coconut sugar
• Cumin
• Jalapenos
• Lime Juice
• Cilantro
• Other recipes you might like:
• 📖 Recipe
• 💬 Comments

Taco night is holy in this house. I don't have a specific day like the hashtag on Instagram dictates, so taco night is usually whenever I feel like it. I'm not very particular about the day but I am very particular about the toppings. There is some leeway when it comes to meat - I can roll with turkey, beef, or meat substitute. I can also roll with the shell - crunchy, soft, corn, cassava. Either are great.

But nothing can spiral me into a panic like realizing last minute that I don't have salsa in the house. I always have salsa! If I don't have salsa, I don't have tacos. I mean, tacos need salsa. Otherwise, it's a bit like PB without the J, like cinnamon toast without cinnamon (or something). Either way, after a mild freak out, my husband called out from the living room: "Just make your own". Hmmm, make my own...of course! I make everything else, so why not make my own salsa!?

After a quick search on the internet and recipes with about 20 ingredients, I decided to just play around with a few ingredients I had in my pantry. And you know what? To my surprise, it turned out great. Like, really great and easy. Now I want to share it with you!

This homemade salsa is:

• Vegan
• Paleo
• Gluten-free
• Grain-free
• Dairy-free
• Ready in minutes
• Super simple to make

Why make your own salsa?

Well, homemade salsa results in a lot more salsa for a lot less money. You also forgo all the additives and preservatives that are often included in jarred salsa.

Plus home made is just healthier all around, as you get to control exactly what goes into it. Which is precisely 9 ingredients!

What do you need to make homemade salsa?

This is the beauty of it; you likely already have most of these ingredients in your kitchen so it's only a matter of putting them together. You'll need:

• Canned petite diced tomatoes
• Fresh baby tomatoes
• Sweet onion
• Coconut sugar
• Cumin
• Lime Juice
• Jalapeños
• Cilantro
• Salt

Tips and Substitutions

Petite diced tomatoes

The first time I made this recipe, I had didn't have jalapeños but had a can of petite diced tomatoes with green chilies I accidentally purchased years ago so I used it as my base. But if you can only find regular petite diced tomatoes, that's perfect.

Baby tomatoes

You can use any kind of small tomato, whether it's grape, cherry or any other small, sweet tomatoes. You want that freshness and sweetness from ripe baby tomatoes.

Onion

I prefer sweet onion (vidalia) for this recipe but if you have red onion, that would work as well. White would also do and last resort would be yellow if none of the other choices are available.

Coconut sugar

If you don't have coconut sugar, you can use regular sugar. The ratio is typically 1 to 1 but I find regular sugar to be a bit sweeter, so start out with ¾ teaspoon first and see if it needs any additional. I find adding sugar to be essential in balancing out the acidity of the tomatoes. I promise it makes all the difference!

Cumin

Cumin is essential in this recipe and cannot be replaced. It's he spice that gives the salsa the depth and flavor and is necessary.

Jalapenos

As I mentioned earlier, if you're able to find petite diced tomatoes with green chilies, you may not need the jalapeño, but otherwise, jalapeño plays an important role in the salsa.

Lime Juice

You can use bottled fresh lime juice or a fresh lime for the salsa, but there are no substitutions for lime as it offers a unique flavor profile that can't be obtained by any other citrus.

Cilantro

Salsa without cilantro just wouldn't work and there really isn't a substitute for it.

Other recipes you might like:

• Mexican Tomato Salad with Black Beans, Corn and Avocado
• Jalapeno Tuna Salad